Wһy Sсotty Didn’t Ask Wһаt Hаppened To Stаr Trek: TOS Crew, Explаined By TNG Writer

Star Trek: The Next Generation writer Ronald D. Moore explains why Scotty didn’t ask about his Enterprise crew when he guest starred in season 6.



  • In “Relics,” Scotty’s lack of curiosity about his former crewmates from Star Trek: The Original Series is addressed by Star Trek: The Next Generation’s writer, Ronald D. Moore.
  • Originally, there was a cut line of dialogue where Troi would ask Scotty if he wanted to know what happened to his friends and family, but Scotty was not ready to hear it.
  • The decision not to directly reference the fate of the other Original Series characters was made to avoid cluttering the episode and locking the show into specific storylines.

Scotty (James Doohan) guest starred in a classic Star Trek: The Next Generation episode, and the show’s writer, Ronald D. Moore, explains why Mr. Scott didn’t ask about his friends from Star Trek: The Original Series. The TNG season 6 episode “Relics” saw Scotty emerge in the 24th century after spending decades in a transporter pattern buffer. But the Chief Engineer known as the “miracle worker” didn’t feel at home aboard the Galaxy Class USS Enterprise-D, and Scotty missed his own Constitution Class Enterprise, “no bloody A, B, C, or D.” Yet Scotty curiously didn’t ask what became of Captain James T. Kirk (William Shatner) and the rest of his crew.

In the Star Trek oral history “The Fifty-Year Mission: The Next 25 Years” by Mark A. Altman and Edward Gross, Ronald D. Moore says that a cut line of dialogue addressed whether Scotty wanted to know what happened to the cast of Star Trek: The Original Series. Read Moore’s explanation in his quote below:

I set out to do a show that was nostalgic and sentimental and that would resonate with what people cared about. Originally, Troi was going to ask Scotty if he wanted to know what happened to his colleagues aboard the Enterprise. There was a line in a scene that got cut out between Troi and Scotty where she said, “Would you like to know what happened to all your friends and family,” and he said, “No, I’m not ready to hear that.” That was the closest allusion we were going to make. My thought is it would clutter it up a little bit to make direct references, since once you bring up Bones and say that Mr. Spock is James Bond now and underground on Romulus, you have to talk about everybody else, and we didn’t want to say what happened to everybody else because we didn’t want to lock ourselves into it.

What Happened To Star Trek: The Original Series’ Crew In TNG’s Era

Captain Kirk’s Enterprise crew hadn’t seen each other for decades.

At the time Star Trek: The Next Generation aired “Relics” in 1992, the series had only addressed the whereabouts of two members of Captain Kirk’s USS Enterprise crew. Dr. Leonard McCoy (DeForrest Kelley) cameoed in TNG‘s series premiere, “Encounter at Farmoint,” as the elderly Admiral McCoy. A year before “Relics,” Ambassador Spock (Leonard Nimoy) guest starred in the TNG season 5 two-parter, “Unification,” which revealed the Vulcan was now living on Romulus and covertly trying to reunite the Vulcan and Romulan people. It was after TNG ended that Star Trek Generations brought in Captain Kirk, who was in the temporal distortion called the Nexus for 78 years.

Captain Kirk died helping Captain Picard stop the madman Dr. Tolian Soran from destroying the planet Veridian III at the end of Star Trek Generations.

Star Trek canon is spotty on what happened to Hikaru Sulu (George Takei), Nyota Uhura (Nichelle Nichols), and Pavel Chekov (Walter Koenig), or whether they were still alive in Star Trek: The Next Generation‘s 24th century. Sulu was Captain of the USS Excelsior, and he appeared in a flashback episode of Star Trek: Voyager. Chekov’s last appearance was in Star Trek Generations‘ 23rd-century prologue alongside Kirk and Scotty, and the movie’s retcon means Mr. Scott believes Kirk died in 2293 when he appeared in Star Trek: The Next Generation.

Star Trek: The Next Generation and Star Trek: The Original Series are available to stream on Paramount+.

Source: “The Fifty-Year Mission: The Next 25 Years: From The Next Generation to J. J. Abrams: The Complete, Uncensored, and Unauthorized Oral History of Star Trek” by Mark A. Altman and Edward Gross

Related Posts

Former 49ers defensive player says QB Brock Purdy “is here to stay”

Logan Ryan appeared in five regular season games for the San Francisco 49ers in 2023. He started two of them. Ryan also played in all three of…

RHOBH: Annemarie Wiley Says She Spoke to One of Crystal “14 Friends,” Calls Her Actions “Pure Evil” and Suggests Crystal’s Living Her “Karma,” See Her Scathing Post

Annemarie Wiley shared she met another member of Crystal Kung Minkoff’s “14 friends” who “dropped her,” hinted that “what she did” to them was “pure evil,” and suggested she’s…

RHONY’s Jenna Lyons Thinks Kyle Richards is “Coming Over” to Her Team and Wants to Style the RHOBH Star Amid Morgan Wade Romance Rumors

Jenna Lyons revealed she would most like to style Kyle Richards because she believes the Real Housewives of Beverly Hills star is “coming over to [her] team.”…

Why Fans Are Focused on Kyle Richards’ Massive Cushion Cut Engagement Ring

People have been paying attention to the RHOBH cast member’s rings amid her separation from Mauricio Umansky.  There’s been a lot of chatter about Kyle Richards and her engagement and wedding…

Lisa Rinna Would ‘Love to Play a Murderer’ After Starring as a ‘Crazy’ Parent in Mommy Meanest (Exclusive)

In the Lifetime movie, Rinna stars as a woman who sends her own daughter anonymous, bullying text messages After Lisa Rinna exited The Real Housewives of Beverly Hills in early 2023,…

REPORT: Paul “PK” Kemsley Storms Off After Chat With Mauricio Umansky, and Steps Out Looking “Frazzled” to Film RHOBH Season 14 Amid Separation, See Video as Insider Speaks on Marriage & Split From Dorit Kemsley

Paul “PK” Kemsley was spotted filming for the upcoming 14th season of The Real Housewives of Beverly Hills on Thursday at The Henry in West Hollywood, California — just as he and his…